The Outsourcing of Logistics

Increasing Supply Chain Flexibility and Cost Effectiveness

In today's supply chain and logistics systems, it is crucial to consider customers' specific needs. Different markets have different priorities, with some being driven primarily by cost and others by the quality of products or services.

For cost-driven markets, the focus is on minimising expenses while ensuring the quality of a specific product or service. On the other hand, quality-driven markets prioritise the excellence of the products or services, with costs being a secondary concern.

One crucial aspect to consider is space. Manufacturing facilities are often located away from the areas where the final product is consumed. This spatial separation necessitates efficient transportation and distribution networks to ensure products promptly reach their destinations. By optimising space utilisation, organisations can minimise costs and maximise efficiency in their supply chain operations.

Another key consideration is time. Organisations rely on inventory management to bridge the gap between supply and demand. By strategically managing inventory levels, organisations can manufacture products at the lowest possible cost and take advantage of reduced transportation expenses.

This is achieved by consolidating finished goods into larger shipments, thereby increasing the utilisation of transportation facilities. Organisations can optimise their supply chain processes by effectively managing time and enhancing overall operational efficiency.

The Benefits of Outsourcing Supply Chain Operations

Historically, major manufacturing organisations like Ford and Unilever operated with vertically integrated supply chains, where the parent company owned most suppliers, service providers, and associated facilities.

It was believed that this approach provided complete control over quality and costs. However, as time has progressed and markets have become more diverse, meeting the demands of these varied markets has become increasingly challenging. The slow pace of change management in large corporate organisations has often hindered market innovation, sales, and profitability.

Recently, there has been a shift towards outsourcing functions that are traditionally considered internal areas of expertise. Rising costs and advancements in IT and ERP systems have driven this change.

As a result, organisations are now questioning whether logistics, once seen as a core area of expertise, should still be managed internally. This shift reflects a growing recognition that external partners may possess specialised knowledge and resources that can enhance efficiency and effectiveness in the supply chain.

The decision to outsource certain functions has its challenges. While it may offer potential benefits such as cost savings and access to specialised expertise, it also introduces new risks and complexities.

Organisations must carefully evaluate the trade-offs and consider factors such as the impact on quality control, customer satisfaction, and overall supply chain visibility. The goal is to balance maintaining control over critical aspects of the supply chain while leveraging external capabilities to drive innovation and meet the evolving needs of diverse markets.

Many organisations focus on enhancing their product or service portfolio, leading them to outsource their logistics functions to third-party logistics (3PL) providers. Outsourcing logistics can include any combination of these tasks:

• Inbound logistics.

• Outbound logistics or distribution.

• Warehousing.

• Inventory management.

• Sales Order Processing (SOP).

• Purchase Order Processing (POP).

• Returns logistics.

• Marketing services requirements.

• IT Services (SOP, POP, MRP I & II and Inventory Management).

• Credit collection of sales invoices (Factoring).

By leveraging the operational efficiencies of these 3PL operators, organisations can achieve a superior level of service while simultaneously cutting costs through economies of scale, minimising their overall logistics costs.

Degrees of Logistics Outsourcing

Fully integrated logistics is referred to as 5PL, whilst partial integration is called 3PL. The outsourcing of logistics can have the following meanings:

• 1PL - First-Party Logistics: First-party logistics refers to an organisation that owns its shipment and freight and can move goods and products from one location to another. They function as the shipper of myriad items and coordinate the delivery of goods to their intended locations. This arrangement primarily benefits the producer or supplier and the purchaser. There are no intermediaries participating in the entire operation.

• 2PL - Second-Party Logistics: The 2PL logistics model involves an organisation subcontracting a carrier or warehouse manager to manage the operational execution of a specific transportation or logistics task. However, an organisation retains the responsibility for organising and overseeing the process. In this model, the relationship between the organisation and the 2PL service provider is typically focused on cost and short-term objectives, with the 2PL service provider following the organisation's instructions and receiving payment accordingly.

• 3PL - Third-Party Logistics: In a 3PL model, an organisation maintains management control while delegating transport and logistics operations to an external supplier who may further subcontract the tasks. A 3PL provider offers a valuable service that allows an organisation to concentrate on other business aspects by overseeing the outsourcing of operational logistics, ranging from warehousing to delivery. 3PL providers offer various supply chain logistics services, such as transportation, warehousing, picking, packing, inventory forecasting, order fulfilment, packaging, and freight forwarding. Given these factors, it is evident that 3PL service providers play a crucial role in ensuring the efficient operation of an organisation.

• 4PL - Fourth-Party Logistics: In the 4PL model, an organisation delegates the management of logistics activities and their implementation across the entire supply chain to external parties. The 4PL service involves more than just outsourcing the coordination of logistical tasks to third parties. It also includes the management of these tasks. 4PL service providers oversee the supply chain, while other parties often delegate administrative and operational activities. These providers usually do not own transportation or warehouse assets, operating as non-asset-based logistics entities. The role of a 4PL logistic provider requires an elevated level of involvement in the organisation's business activities. In addition to outsourcing logistics processes, an organisation expects the service provider to monitor them. Instead of short-term collaboration agreements based solely on cost considerations, the focus shifts to long-term partnerships that prioritise service quality and involve shared risks and benefits. A 4PL service provider acts as a supply chain integrator, bringing together and managing all the resources, capabilities, and technology required for an organisation's supply chain, including its network of providers.

• 5PL - Fifth-Party logistics: 5PL logistics services can strengthen demand. Furthermore, a 5PL service provider engages in rate negotiations with various other service providers, including trucks and airlines. A 5PL operator is a logistics service provider that effectively plans, organises, and executes logistics solutions for different commercial organisations. The 5PL service provider can fortify demand by negotiating rates with other service providers, like trucks, airlines, etc. Organisations that delegate logistics management functions to external parties are a prime example of this solution. The concept of 5PL has gained significant attention recently, particularly with the rise of e-commerce. In addition to integrating and managing the supply chain, 5PL organisations offer other valuable services such as call centres and online payment systems.

Critics of outsourcing logistics to a 3PL, 4PL or 5PL service operator often need clarification on whether the promised cost savings are achieved. They argue that the need for more control over the logistics process is a significant reason organisations should not opt for outsourcing. In the logistics industry, larger organisations manage their logistics needs internally. In comparison, smaller and medium organisations are more inclined to outsource to cut costs. 

Outsourcing some or all aspects of logistics can give organisations access to the expertise, knowledge, and experience of third-party service providers. This can result in cost reductions while improving service levels beyond what the organisation could achieve. Additionally, cash flow may see a positive impact as logistics service providers typically charge based on the number of consignments, ensuring they cover their costs and make a reasonable profit. 

The decision to outsource logistics functions should be carefully considered based on each organisation's specific needs and circumstances. While there are valid concerns about control and cost savings, outsourcing can offer valuable benefits regarding expertise and service quality. Organisations can determine the best approach to managing their logistics operations effectively by weighing the pros and cons.

Additional articles can be found at Procurement Made Easy. This site looks at procurement issues to assist organisations and people in increasing the quality, efficiency, and effectiveness of their product and service supply to the customers' delight. ©️ Procurement Made Easy. All rights reserved.